As a prank, [Character A] steals the House Mug from Mr. Merrill's office (where it is displayed in a place of honour), but accidentally loses their grip on it while escaping. The Mug shatters into a dozen pieces after falling off the third floor balcony.

A day later, Mr. Merrill replaces the House Mug with an Azurcrest blue demitasse from the kitchens. No one understands why the Fishy Foxy Forest Fighters look horrified.