Here I am, late to the party as usual.

Jeremy can be that past ex of hers in freshman year! They're in the same year, so time-wise it would definitely work. That was when he was at his wildest, so it works out that they'd have gotten along well then. Like a fast and furious fling that fizzled out when he was trying that reformed bad boy suit and she discovered she was far more interested in macking on girls. :)

Wyatt is a baby and probably doesn't even register on Faye's radar, lbr.